A three-person narrow raft like the Flycraft Guide or NRS Approach 138 is a fantastic option for anglers who want the flexibility of a small raft that can still carry a couple of friends and all their gear. Choosing the right fishing raft for an adventure can be a big decision, especially when you need one that's portable but also capable.
In the world of compact rafts, two models stand out: the NRS Approach 138 and the Flycraft Guide. While they might look similar at first glance, a closer look reveals some key differences that could help you decide which one is the perfect fit for your next trip.
Weight of Flycraft Guide vs Approach 138
One of the most significant differences between these two rafts is their weight.
The Flycraft Guide is a lean 145 pounds, thanks to its simpler frame. It's much easier to load and unload by yourself.
The NRS Approach 138 weighs 220 pounds. This extra weight comes from a heavier-duty frame, two rigid aluminum storage boxes, and more durable material in high-wear areas.
Cost of the Flycraft Guide vs Approach 138
The Flycraft Guide has a base price of $5,445 (with no oars, anchor, or storage rack). A full “angler package” can bring the total up to $7,255.
The NRS Approach 138 starts at a higher price of $6,395, but it includes key features like storage boxes and rod storage. When you add the optional oars package, the total comes to around $7,095.
So, when you compare the boats with a similar set of features, the FlyCraft can actually end up costing about $200 more. This makes the overall value of the two boats very similar.
Speed Compared
Both boats are designed for moving water and perform similarly in terms of speed. They are built to float with the current, using oars to slow your drift for fishing. Both can also be outfitted with a motor for faster travel. The speed of both rafts are comparable using a Torqeedo electric motor.
Maneuverability & Stability Compared
Both the NRS Approach 138 and the Flycraft Guide are easy to maneuver and are highly stable. The NRS boat's slightly larger tube diameter provides a bit more flotation, but both rafts feature a drop-stitched floor. This makes them incredibly stable for standing and moving around, even with a full crew.
Durability of the Approach 138 vs Guide
The NRS Approach 138 has a slight edge in durability. Its frame is built to be a little heavier and more robust, and the raft itself has more reinforced layers of material in high-wear areas compared to the Flycraft Guide. This added protection means the NRS will likely hold up longer under heavy use.
Features, Storage & Rigging
The NRS Approach 138 excels in this category. Its rigid storage boxes and frame's track system provide a clear advantage for stowing gear and customizing your setup. The FlyCraft is a simpler platform, and while accessories can be added, you'll likely need to use clamps or glue-on mounts for aftermarket additions.
Flycraft Guide
The simple design of the Flycraft Guide and swivel seats are a major plus. This is great for anglers who need to cast in any direction. Its lighter weight and simplicity are a huge advantage for those who value quick rigging and easy setup. Although some accessories are sold separately.
NRS Approach 138
This raft comes standard with built-in rod storage, a motor mount, and valuable under-seat storage boxes. Its frame has a track system that allows you to easily adjust seat positions and add accessories, offering good customization.
Fishability of the Flycraft Guide vs Approach 138
Both narrow fishing rafts are excellent for fishing, offering ample space and comfortable seating. The FlyCraft's swivel seats make it easy to cast from a seated position, while the NRS Approach 138 offers a foot brace for more leverage when rowing in fast current. Ultimately, both boats provide a great platform for fly-fishing and casting.
Value of Flycraft Guide vs Approach 138
When it comes to price, these boats are surprisingly similar once you outfit them with comparable features. A basic Flycraft Guide is less expensive, but adding accessories to match the NRS’s standard features brings the price up. The NRS Approach 138 also comes with a more generous 5-year warranty for personal use, compared to the Flycraft’s 3-year warranty.
Which Three Person Fishing Raft?
Both rafts are excellent choices for river fishing. If you want a simple, lightweight three-person raft that's easy to get on and off the water, choose the Flycraft Guide. However, if you need a more durable, feature-rich boat with plenty of storage and rigging options, you might find the NRS Approach 138 to be a perfect fit.
For a deeper dive, check out the NRS Approach 138 review from a multi-day adventure.
