Ah, the age-old debate: hiking shoes versus hiking boots. This very question is posed by just about every new hiker looking to begin their journey. The reason for this debate is pretty simple, and that's that higher quality shoes and boots cost a lot of money, and people want to get as much mileage out of their purchase as possible. That's completely understandable, and it's a fair question to ask. So, let's ask it!
The Great Debate: Hiking Shoes vs Hiking Boots
It's common to see lightweight hiking shoes described as “nimble, but unstable”, while their heavier counterparts fit the role of “supportive, but clunky”, whereas the truth is a little more muddy than you might expect. Shoes and boots tend to do the exact same thing – they protect your feet – and they will do it well if you buy a high quality pair. The difference often comes down to personal preference.
Hiking Shoes: Light and Nimble
Hiking shoes, in my opinion, are the default all-around winners. Very, very rarely have I been in a position where I curse myself for bringing shoes as opposed to boots. Shoes tend to be lighter, more breathable, and more relaxing to wear. People say that shoes are less supportive than boots, but you'll often find that they are much more supportive than your average footwear, with aggressive treads that cling to the terrain.
You'll find that the big drawback of hiking shoes comes when you have to muscle through unfavorable terrain. Muddy, wet, slippery, or jagged conditions will leave you wanting something a little more purpose-built strapped to your feet.
Hiking Boots: Sturdy and Supportive
Hiking boots, on the other hand, tend to be a bit heavier (though often not as much as you'd think), and offer more in the way of protection. Is that protection always necessary? No. Would you be fine wearing shoes in most circumstances? Yup. However, boots have their time and place.
I've been in situations where the stability and protection of a good boot makes me feel like king of the mountain, with ankles of iron and an unfailing grip on the rocks below…. though I've also been in situations where all I wanted to do was lose my beefy boots in favor of something lighter and more breathable.
Making the Choice: It's All About Context
So, how do you decide? If you're new to hiking, I'd suggest investing in a solid pair of boots, and break out your old tennis shoes on the easier trails for the time being. I'd rather have good boots and not need them, than need them and not have them – and I'm sure you'll find that tennis shoes are often good enough!
Choose What Works, Hiking Shoes vs Hiking Boots
Ultimately, the choice between hiking shoes and boots isn't a one-size-fits-all decision. It's about finding what works best for your adventure style, comfort level, and the specific conditions you'll encounter out there. Don't be afraid to try out different options or borrow gear from friends to see what suits you best.
As for me, I've come to appreciate both hiking shoes and boots for their unique strengths. Sometimes its a shoe day, sometimes it's a boot day – and sometimes it's time to rock sandals.
At the end of the day, your goal is to have so much fun that you don't even notice what's strapped to your feet. Read another blog article about the best hiking shoes and hiking boots for 2022.
Until next time, happy trails!
Mike Fink
